The Arc of California Condemns ICE’s Violent Detention of Student with Developmental Disability

A statement by Jordan Lindsey, Executive Director, The Arc of California

I am outraged and deeply disturbed by reports that federal immigration agents violently detained and injured a 20-year-old student with a developmental disability while he was simply walking to school in Santa Maria, California.

According to a media report, this young man, a U.S. citizen with limited verbal communication, was tackled, handcuffed, and placed in an ICE vehicle before being released. He then made his way to school, where staff called an ambulance. His injuries reportedly included a broken wrist requiring surgery, along with bruises and lacerations.

This is absolutely unacceptable. It is a horrifying example of the danger that aggressive, indiscriminate immigration enforcement tactics pose to people with intellectual and developmental disabilities.

What makes this incident particularly heartbreaking is that this young man had worked for years to develop the confidence and independence to walk to school on his own. That independence, something we work tirelessly to support for people with developmental disabilities, has now been undermined by a traumatic encounter with federal agents. He reportedly told his former teacher that he feared he was going to die.

Even more disturbing is ICE’s explanation that the student allegedly resisted commands and did not request medical assistance. For someone with limited verbal communication, these statements raise serious questions about whether agents recognized or appropriately responded to his disability. A person’s disability-related communication challenges must never be mistaken for defiance, used to justify unnecessary force, or become a barrier to receiving medical attention.

The Arc of California has previously condemned ICE enforcement practices that instill fear in communities, threaten the safety of people with disabilities, and undermine their basic civil rights. This incident illustrates precisely why we have sounded that alarm.

And while this student is a U.S. citizen, let me be absolutely clear: No person, regardless of immigration status, race, or disability, deserves to be treated this way. Every person is entitled to dignity, safety, and fundamental constitutional protections.

We demand an immediate, independent, and transparent investigation into this incident, full accountability for any misconduct, and meaningful safeguards to protect people with intellectual and developmental disabilities from similar encounters. We also renew our call to end aggressive immigration enforcement activities in and around schools and other settings where people with disabilities receive education, care, and essential services.

The Arc of California stands with this young man, his educators, and the Santa Maria community. We will continue speaking out against enforcement practices that endanger people with disabilities and violate the fundamental principles of dignity, inclusion, and human rights.

People with developmental disabilities should be able to walk to school, participate in their communities, and live their lives without fear of violence from the very institutions entrusted with protecting the public.

This must never happen again.

Download the Know Your Rights Guides

In Pursuit of Justice: Attorney General Bonta Files Felony Charges Against the Ex-LAPD Officer Who Shot and Killed Kenneth French and Critically Wounded His Parents

August 16, 2021

by Teresa Anderson, Director, Public Policy

First and foremost, I want the French family to know that we continue to hold them in our hearts and admire them greatly for their strength and persistence in pursuing justice for their son and family. In June 2019 Kenneth, a young man with disabilities, and his parents were shopping at Costco in Corona, California (Riverside County) when Kenneth was shot and killed by, then off-duty LAPD officer, Salvador Sanchez. Russell and Paola French, Kenneth’s parents, were also shot and critically wounded during the shooting. This senseless tragedy was made even worse when Riverside County District Attorney Mike Hestrin announced that no charges would be brought against the off-duty officer based on a grand jury’s failure to indict. Hestrin issued a statement saying, in part, that “charges against the officer were not warranted.”  The disability community was outraged by such blatant disregard for the life of a young man with disabilities and complete lack of accountability for the officer who killed him. Kenneth was an unarmed young man with a disability who was shot in the back, and his parents were shot while trying to protect him…charges were more than warranted, they were expected.

Failure to hold this officer accountable sent shock waves through the community, moving advocates, families, loved ones, to organize protests, meet with elected officials, and demand a meeting with the Riverside County District Attorney’s Office to find out how the system could have failed this family and the community. Thank you to EVERYONE who wrote letters, signed onto letters, met with elected officials, went to the protest sites (Riverside County and the LAPD), and otherwise expressed your outrage at such a failure of justice. It is because of the strength and persistence of the French family, their loved ones, and the power of advocacy within the disability community that this shooting became so “high profile” that it led the Attorney General to step in and demand justice and accountability.

Historically, officer-involved shootings that result in the death of an unarmed person were investigated by local law enforcement and the District Attorneys. However, Assembly Bill 1506, which became effective July 1, 2021, created a mandate for an independent, statewide prosecutor to investigate and review officer-involved shootings of unarmed civilians, including assessing for potential criminal liability. The intent behind the law is to help build and maintain trust between law enforcement and the community. This is critically important to the disability community because research shows that between 30%-50% of officer-involved shootings involve a person with a disability.  The Attorney General’s (AG) decision to charge Mr. Sanchez came about after an independent review of proceedings at the local level and the belief that a crime was in fact committed. The AG’s statement can be read here: https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-bonta-announces-arrest-and-filing-felony-charges-against-duty

We know building trust between the law enforcement community and the disability community will take time and be an on-going process, but we believe the AG stepping in to ensure accountability and justice for the French family is a step in the right direction.